YouTube recommends a video when viewers respond to it: they click, keep watching, and watch something else afterwards. It does not see the hours you put in. When views are low, two numbers tell you why. Click-through rate shows whether the title and thumbnail work, and retention shows whether the video does. Compare both with your own earlier videos, fix one thing in the next upload, and give a niche about fifty videos before you judge it.
Plays from YouTube when you press play. Watch on YouTube
What YouTube rewards: the viewer's response
Victor Catrina compared faceless channels that grew with ones that stalled. The stalled ones optimised for information and the growing ones for attention. The system reacts to what viewers do: whether they click, stay, comment and watch another video. His exercise is to notice your own behaviour as a viewer, why you click away or watch a second video, and apply that to your own videos. Work first on the changes that can double a result, and leave the last 1% for later. Victor Catrina 1:35
The analytics that matter, and the ones to ignore
The two that matter:
- Click-through rate (CTR): of the people shown the thumbnail, how many clicked.
- Average view duration and retention: how long they stayed.
Fabio Morena's benchmarks from his own channels: a CTR above 7 to 8% and an average view duration above 45% of the video. Check retention at 30 seconds to judge the intro. The audience tab also shows which other channels your viewers watch, which is a list of channels to study. Fabio Morena 1:25:15
What to ignore. Nate Curtiss explains why overall CTR falls as a video spreads: it is shown to people further from your core audience, who click less. So a falling CTR on a growing video is a good sign. He also ignores early views, subscriber counts and like ratios. What he watches:
- CTR in the first 24 hours, compared only with his own videos;
- average view duration against his videos of similar length;
- 60 to 70% of viewers still watching at 30 seconds;
- dips in the retention graph, and what happened on screen at that moment;
- the share of new viewers, since most watch time should come from people who are not subscribed yet.
All these benchmarks are the creators' own. Your niche will differ, which is why the comparison with your own average is the one to trust.
Early-view mistakes
Romayroh lists three things people do in the first hours that hurt a video:
- Sharing the link with friends and family. They watch a few seconds to be kind, and those short views pull the average view duration down. Watching part of your own upload does the same; check the video fully before you publish.
- Buying views or subscribers. Paid traffic teaches YouTube the wrong audience, and it breaks YouTube's fake engagement policy, which bans anything that artificially increases views, likes or subscribers (Help, last checked 14 November 2026).
- Deleting videos with few views. Videos take off late. He shows one that spiked after about 250 days.
Sharing and paying for reach: what YouTube says. Creators contradict each other on this, sometimes in their own comment sections. YouTube Help settles part of it (read 17 November 2026):
- Sharing a link is fine. YouTube's own advice is to link your channel in as many places as you can. It does not say that visits from outside help or hurt recommendations. The damage Romayroh describes comes from people who click to be kind and leave after a few seconds. Share a video where people want that topic, and not with friends who do not.
- YouTube's own "Promote" is not the same as buying views. It is YouTube's ad product inside Studio, and it is allowed. One creator tells his viewers it damages a channel. YouTube says the opposite: promotions do not change how a video is recommended. It also says the watch hours and subscribers they bring do not count towards the Partner Program; only what those viewers go on to watch by themselves afterwards does, in one type of promotion. So it will not hurt, and it will not get you monetized sooner. On a new channel, fix the title and thumbnail before you pay for anything.
When to wait and when to change packaging
The creators disagree about changing a title or thumbnail after publishing.
- Leave it. Romayroh argues that swaps rarely rescue a faceless video. He gets the packaging right before publishing, stays away from analytics for three to four days, and uses CTR and view duration to improve the next video. Romayroh 9:03
- Change it on evidence. After about thirty uploads, Make Money Matt compares each video's CTR with the channel average and tests a new thumbnail where a video falls below it. Make Money Matt 13:00
Both rest on the same point: decide from your own numbers, and not in the first hours. The lesson on titles goes into the rule for changing one.
Shorts view jail
Two patterns, in E'Calm's experience:
- Stuck at zero. He believes YouTube is treating the account as automated, and uses a new account as a normal viewer for at least five days first. (See the lesson on channel trust; YouTube does not confirm this mechanism.)
- Stuck around 10,000. A retention problem. His targets: above 85% for a Short of 50 to 60 seconds, and above 100%, meaning rewatches, for one of 15 to 40 seconds.
When to keep pushing and when to pivot
Fabio Morena's rule: at least 50 videos, about two a week for six months, before you consider changing niche. If none has passed 100,000 views by then, look at your competitors:
- They still get views: the niche works and your videos are the problem. Fix the videos.
- They are flat too: the niche has cooled. Consider a new one.
You can rename and redirect an existing channel instead of starting again. Fabio Morena 1:30:10
The 100,000 mark fits his niches. In a small niche with a high rate per 1,000 views, a lower mark is reasonable. The question to ask stays the same: is it the niche or the videos?
Checklist
Your ticks are saved in this browser only.
Income and view figures mentioned in these videos are the creators' own claims and are not verified.

